Contact Us
Pound Ridge Daily Voice serves Pound Ridge, NY

Menu

Pound Ridge Daily Voice serves Pound Ridge, NY
Breaking News: Tropical Depression Cindy Expected To Impact Pound Ridge
real estate Content Partnership

Former Speakeasy and Inn, Mount Kisco Home Tells An Interesting Tale

23 Byram Lake Road in Mount Kisco was originally purchased from Native Americans in 1777, then renovated and repurposed as a tavern, inn and theater.
23 Byram Lake Road in Mount Kisco was originally purchased from Native Americans in 1777, then renovated and repurposed as a tavern, inn and theater. Photo Credit: Justin White
23 Byram Lake Road in Mount Kisco was originally purchased from Native Americans in 1777, then renovated and repurposed as a tavern, inn and theater.
23 Byram Lake Road in Mount Kisco was originally purchased from Native Americans in 1777, then renovated and repurposed as a tavern, inn and theater. Photo Credit: Anthony Martone
23 Byram Lake Road in Mount Kisco was originally purchased from Native Americans in 1777, then renovated and repurposed as a tavern, inn and theater.
23 Byram Lake Road in Mount Kisco was originally purchased from Native Americans in 1777, then renovated and repurposed as a tavern, inn and theater. Photo Credit: Anthony Martone
23 Byram Lake Road in Mount Kisco was originally purchased from Native Americans in 1777, then renovated and repurposed as a tavern, inn and theater.
23 Byram Lake Road in Mount Kisco was originally purchased from Native Americans in 1777, then renovated and repurposed as a tavern, inn and theater. Photo Credit: Anthony Martone
23 Byram Lake Road in Mount Kisco was originally purchased from Native Americans in 1777, then renovated and repurposed as a tavern, inn and theater.
23 Byram Lake Road in Mount Kisco was originally purchased from Native Americans in 1777, then renovated and repurposed as a tavern, inn and theater. Photo Credit: Antony Martone

MOUNT KISCO, N.Y. --   If the walls could talk at 23 Byram Lake Road in Mount Kisco, they would tell a story spanning much of American history. Originally purchased from Native Americans in 1777, the northern Westchester home served as a mill, tavern and inn during its nearly 250-year history.

Joan Keating of William Raveis Real Estate is listing the property for $965,000, a competitive price from such a remarkable house. "This home is not only beautiful inside and out, but it has a rich history in Westchester," she said.

The first family to build a home on the Byram Lake Road property were the Flewellyns, a Mount Kisco family during the late 18th century, who used the property as a mill. After the family sold the home in the mid-1800's, the property, then spanning over 80 acres, belonged to the Kirby family, who were prominent local businesspeople and were the reason Mount Kisco was once called "Kirbyville." Years later, the property was then used as a residence for the staff of Luigi De Cesnola, the first director of The Metropolitan Museum of Art in Manhattan.

However, at the turn of the century, new owners saw an opportunity to use the house as more than just a residence.

During America's Prohibition, the home operated as The Silver Moon, a local speakeasy. Just over a decade later, 23 Byram Lake Road was purchased by a retired school teacher, Effie Phyfe, who turned the speakeasy into an inn known as The Tavern in Mt. Kisco. The Tavern hosted many of film's early stars, including Henry Ford, Ethel Barrymore, Vincent Price and others. Frank Sinatra, Mia Farrow and the Reagans all also visited the inn as well.

"I love telling my clients about the history of this home and all the wonderful people who have visited this property," said Keating. "Today, the home is updated to feature all the modern conveniences, but the halls still tell tales of over 200 years of history,"

For more information on 23 Byram Lake Road, or to see other listings by Joan Keating, click here.

Daily Voice produced this article as part of a paid Content Partnership with our advertiser, William Raveis Real Estate - Joan Keating

We are highly selective with our Content Partners, and only share stories that we believe are truly valuable to the communities we serve.

To learn more about Content Partnerships, click here.

Share this story

Welcome to

Pound Ridge Daily Voice!

This is a one time message inviting you to keep in touch

Get important news about your town as it happens.